Mobius Forum Archive

Whoever Posts Last ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Whoever Posts Last Wins Too 4: monthly winners, no fads, READ RULES FIRST!

2,222 Posts
75 Users
0 Reactions
11.2 K Views
(@hybrid-project-alpha)
Posts: 1104
Noble Member
 

What fun

 
(@hukos)
Posts: 1986
Noble Member
 

What fun?

 
(@chaorcute)
Posts: 981
Noble Member
 

Yes.

 
(@hybrid-project-alpha)
Posts: 1104
Noble Member
(@gt-koopa)
Posts: 2417
Famed Member
 

That was epic.

Nothing will ever top that. NOTHING.

 
(@chaorcute)
Posts: 981
Noble Member
(@mokat)
Posts: 140
Estimable Member
 

Aptimus! I refuse to fill out yer stinkin' forms! -.-

*thwaps EZ-Board and "network.aptimus.com/" with Ultima Weapon and Ragnarok while winning*

 
(@hukos)
Posts: 1986
Noble Member
 

*And re-takes the win*

 
(@sailor-unicron)
Posts: 1694
Noble Member
 

*re-retakes the win*

 
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
New Member Guest
 

I haven't posted in this in months

 
(@dreamer-of-nights)
Posts: 2354
Noble Member
Topic starter
 

And so it'll continue!

** edited rules 'cause I can and you non-mod, non-admin people can't while winning **

 
(@hybrid-project-alpha)
Posts: 1104
Noble Member
 

fffff

 
(@dreamer-of-nights)
Posts: 2354
Noble Member
Topic starter
 

wtf is this?

 
(@hukos)
Posts: 1986
Noble Member
 

lolcat?

 
(@hybrid-project-alpha)
Posts: 1104
Noble Member
 

Delicious

 
 Srol
(@srol_1722027881)
Posts: 917
Noble Member
 

&nbsp &nbsp &nbsp &nbsp The facts of this case are as follows. Judith Watkins was the first ever female football player at Jefferson High School, and was originally a subject of controversy. However she ceased to be controversial after making significant contributions to the team. However, at the beginning of her 2nd season, the coach announced she was leaving the team due to medical reasons. An investigating reporter found out indirectly through an interview with a disgruntled assistant coach that Judith actually left the team due to the fact that she was pregnant. After confirming this with other staff members, the reporter returns to his producer, who as the moral agent must decide whether or not it is ethical to broadcast this information.
&nbsp &nbsp &nbsp &nbsp Some conflicts that are set up in this case study include the publics right to know versus privacy and the role of the student versus the role of the athlete.
Analysis
In terms of the publics right to know versus the privacy of the individual, it is impossible to decide which principle is more important overall. They must be weighed on a case by case basis. In this particular case, it is difficult because a double-standard exists. It is assumed, in areas where high school sports are covered, that you will cover the victories and exultations, yet ignore the scandals and losses. In my mind a double standard cannot exist. If the press has made a decision that these football players are newsworthy, then they are always newsworthy. If they decide that they are not, then they are never newsworthy, and can never be covered until such an event occurs that might make them newsworthy. In the area of the role of the student versus the role of the athlete, it is not the responsibility of the press to decide which is more important. The reporter cannot go around making each childs life decision for him or her. In this case, Judith Watkins has decided to become an athlete with a school that holds athletics as primary over academics. She has already made her choice. It should not be the presss job to second-guess it.
&nbsp &nbsp &nbsp &nbsp In this case, I believe that the moral agent has a duty to the public first of all. The moral agents station has covered the football team all year through thick and thin. The people are relying on the moral agent to provide them with the truth. Even a withholding of information would be a betrayal of this trust. Secondly, I believe that the moral agent has an obligation to Judith Watkins. Whether or not they decide to go forward with this story, Judith Watkins will be affected. There are too many possibilities to say for sure, but 50% of the possibilities will be impossibilities based on the moral agents decision. The final obligation is to the larger journalism community. The escalation of coverage of high school sports is an issue that is only going to get larger. Journalists (and lawyers) across the country are going to look to this theory as precedent in deciding future cases dealing with high school athletes.
&nbsp &nbsp &nbsp &nbsp One theory that could possibly apply to this case is Rawls theory of Social Justice. Egalitarianism would state that if we treated Judith Watkins one way during last season, then we must continue to treat her that way, as her status as a newsworthy subject has not changed. If anything, her newsworthiness has heightened due to the scandal surrounding her departure, and as a result the moral agent has an even greater responsibility to expose her decision to leave. Aristotles Golden Mean has a similar, but slightly less extreme solution. If the two extremes in this situation are to expose her, or keep silent, the Golden Mean would be to release the information but in a manner dignifying to Ms. Watkins.
Decision
&nbsp &nbsp &nbsp &nbsp Taking the position of the producer Oliver Holmes, I believe that the cable system should run a story covering the actual reasons behind Judith Watkins leaving the team. The fact that the coach called a press conference to inform the press the false reasons for Judith leaving alone says that he considers the story to be newsworthy. If the cable systems were overly concerned about their obligation to treat the high school athletes as students rather than celebrities, that obligation should have been addressed before they first began covering them. As a result, a judgment on this issue has partially already been rendered
This theory is based on Rawls demand that the story be broached, however Id like to temper it with Aristotle. I am not suggesting that the cable system release the story right out on the breaking news. The reporters should approach Ms. Watkins in private and inform her that her trainers and coaches are giving this information away without regard for her well-being. Offer her the chance to tell her story before it eventually gets out through others and makes the already churning rumor mill even worse. If Ms. Watkins still refuses, inform her that you plan to run the story with or without her testimony. This way, even if she refuses to co-operate, she still has time to make adjustments so that the when the story breaks it will not affect her as badly. As a result, she is still treated equally under Egalitarianism, but a compromise is reached through the Golden Mean.

 
(@hybrid-project-alpha)
Posts: 1104
Noble Member
 

fffffffffffffffffffffffffff

 
(@chaorcute)
Posts: 981
Noble Member
 

fffffffffffffffffffffffffff +1

 
(@hybrid-project-alpha)
Posts: 1104
Noble Member
 

DNE

 
(@hukos)
Posts: 1986
Noble Member
 

DINNER

 
(@gt-koopa)
Posts: 2417
Famed Member
 

MAH BOI

 
(@hybrid-project-alpha)
Posts: 1104
Noble Member
 

squish

 
(@hukos)
Posts: 1986
Noble Member
 

Never.

 
(@shifty)
Posts: 1058
Noble Member
 

I've never had THIS kind of fun before!

"wether we try to avoide it or not we all ate insects."-sonicsfan1991

 
(@hukos)
Posts: 1986
Noble Member
 

And you shall never have it ever again.

 
(@sailor-unicron)
Posts: 1694
Noble Member
 

How can you be sure?

 
(@hybrid-project-alpha)
Posts: 1104
Noble Member
 

*rolls in chopped almonds*

 
(@hukos)
Posts: 1986
Noble Member
 

How many?

 
(@hybrid-project-alpha)
Posts: 1104
Noble Member
 

OVER NINE THOUSAAAAAAAAAAAND!!

 
(@hukos)
Posts: 1986
Noble Member
 

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

 
(@dreamer-of-nights)
Posts: 2354
Noble Member
Topic starter
 

Congratulations to HPA on becoming the first winner of 2008.

 
(@hybrid-project-alpha)
Posts: 1104
Noble Member
 

*kiss* :3

 
(@dreamer-of-nights)
Posts: 2354
Noble Member
Topic starter
 

your victory goodbye? Very yes.

 
(@hukos)
Posts: 1986
Noble Member
 

Very no

 
(@dreamer-of-nights)
Posts: 2354
Noble Member
Topic starter
 

Bump! I win my first topic in yuku!

Let's see how long will I last.

 
(@gt-koopa)
Posts: 2417
Famed Member
 

Don't tell anyone, but I'm linking Yugioh the Abridged Series Episode 27 here so if someone makes a new thread about it I have the right to say "NO! It has been posted already!"Because no one posts in Whoever Post Lasts Wins anyway until the end of the month! Its flawless! The end of the month must be weeks from now because Brawl opens in March and we all know that won't come out in USville ever! It is delayed to infinity!!! Plus it is a leap year so that is like a whole day longer! Perfect scheme!

 
(@kiorein_1722585747)
Posts: 713
Prominent Member
 

That was a good episode = )

 
(@hybrid-project-alpha)
Posts: 1104
Noble Member
 

I don't watch TV

 
(@dreamer-of-nights)
Posts: 2354
Noble Member
Topic starter
 

And HPA wins the month. Again.

 
(@hybrid-project-alpha)
Posts: 1104
Noble Member
 

o.o

 
(@hukos)
Posts: 1986
Noble Member
 

Damn it!

 
(@kiorein_1722585747)
Posts: 713
Prominent Member
 

Oh snap it's an actual competition

 
(@dreamer-of-nights)
Posts: 2354
Noble Member
Topic starter
 

Oh no! I'd just realized!

Yes, it's an actual competition on which you just lost and I just won.

kthnxbye

 
(@hyper-shadow-x)
Posts: 209
Estimable Member
 

*pops in for instant win* o.o

 
(@hukos)
Posts: 1986
Noble Member
 

*Takes the instant win*

Thank you.

 
(@sailor-unicron)
Posts: 1694
Noble Member
 

So the win has evolved into the instant win?

*swipes the instant win and flees*

 
(@hukos)
Posts: 1986
Noble Member
 

It's faster.

*Takes it back*

 
(@the-turtle-guy)
Posts: 3756
Famed Member
 

*nabs the Progressive Win over some time*

 
(@dreamer-of-nights)
Posts: 2354
Noble Member
Topic starter
 

So much for that TTG.

 
(@the-ultimate-lifeformess)
Posts: 174
Estimable Member
 

XD It's been a LONG time since I played this game.

 
Page 25 / 45
Share: