Mobius Forum Archive

Why it stinks to ha...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Why it stinks to have a good idea about the comic

21 Posts
13 Users
0 Reactions
126 Views
(@alex-warlorn)
Posts: 337
Reputable Member
Topic starter
 

It stinks that I've had a good idea about the comic. Because if I mention it, then the Sonic writers won't be able to use it, because it's outside material. (True they didn't stop them from using my Metal Sonic Army idea without giving me an acknowledgement, but hey).

So, in the vain hope a writer who works for the comic will come up with the same idea, I can't say my idea, which stinks.

 
(@sailor-unicron)
Posts: 1694
Noble Member
 

Um, isn't that what fanfiction is for?

 
(@matt7325)
Posts: 1446
Noble Member
 

Quote:


True they didn't stop them from using my Metal Sonic Army idea without giving me an acknowledgement, but hey


You've said this several times now. Give us some definitive proof, and not just "I wrote a fanfic about lots of Metal Sonics making trouble."

 
(@tornadot)
Posts: 1567
Noble Member
 

Instead of worrying about your situation, why not start writing? Maybe if you improve your writing skill and write imaginative stories, down the line they can hire you and you may implement your wonderful storylines.

 
(@miss-puar)
Posts: 462
Reputable Member
 

Forumer A: I've got an idea for the Sonic comics but I can't tell you what it is.
Forumer B: Is it about Metal Sonic Armies?
Forumer A: AARGH! Get outta my head!

 
(@charlesrocketboy)
Posts: 462
Honorable Member
 

Well, it's not like there was another Sonic comic that had an army of Metal Sonics that they could've gotten the idea from.

 
(@true-red_1722027886)
Posts: 1583
Noble Member
 

Heh 😉 @ Charles

The writers don't even pay attention to fan creations. There's such a thing as someone else having the same idea as you on their own.

 
(@darkest-light)
Posts: 1376
Noble Member
 

Quote:


The writers don't even pay attention to fan creations. There's such a thing as someone else having the same idea as you on their own and having the influence to implement it


Fixed for clarification.

 
(@hypershadow77)
Posts: 1402
Noble Member
 

Quote:


Well, it's not like there was another Sonic comic that had an army of Metal Sonics that they could've gotten the idea from.


i totally thought the same thing. lol

 
(@true-red_1722027886)
Posts: 1583
Noble Member
 

lol @ fix

Works for me. 😀

 
(@alex-warlorn)
Posts: 337
Reputable Member
Topic starter
 

Allow me to clarify.

Back on the TSF message board, and the original Netraptor Message board, I wrote an request for a piece of artwork.

With Sonic, Shadow, and Metal Sonic MK III fighting off a horde of Metal Sonic MK Is on top of a pile of already destroyed ones.

With Red Emperor in the back ground.

Sound familiar?

 
(@true-red_1722027886)
Posts: 1583
Noble Member
 

Alex, if you're not going to pay attention to the fact that Archie creatives aren't even visiting tSfMB nor Netraptor's (among other places), then there's really no hope for you.

 
(@samanfur-the-fox)
Posts: 2116
Noble Member
 

What Red said. They don't visit those places for that exact reason.

 
(@alex-warlorn)
Posts: 337
Reputable Member
Topic starter
 

Plagiarism exists.

 
(@crazy-cham-lea_1722585730)
Posts: 622
Honorable Member
 

So does coincidence. Especially when developing something from the same source material.

 
(@samanfur-the-fox)
Posts: 2116
Noble Member
 

Hence that whole Mina the Mongoose/Mimic the Moonrat mess a few years ago - and the fan character'd never even been pitched to Archie.

 
(@sailor-unicron)
Posts: 1694
Noble Member
 

Mimic the Moonrat? First time I've heard of it. What happened?

 
(@crazy-cham-lea_1722585730)
Posts: 622
Honorable Member
 

When Mina Mongoose first appeared, it was noted that her design was similar to that of fan-character Mimic the Moonrat. IIRC both had yellow fur, rounded ears and long, lilac hair.

 
(@samanfur-the-fox)
Posts: 2116
Noble Member
 

And Mimic's creator was convinced that it was a case of character theft, and was reportedly very upset.

But I wouldn't have said that the design was that unique - and especially not when you're dealing with a series that seems to have a limited number of ways of depicting canines, rodents and whatnot.

 
(@rico-underwood)
Posts: 2928
Famed Member
 

OMG! Sam is a fox like Rico! LAWLSUIT!

~Rico

 
(@chibibecca_1722585688)
Posts: 3291
Famed Member
 

*blinks* i've known mimic for years and i compleately missed out on that. o.o;

 
Share: