Mobius Forum Archive

A logical Riddle...
 
Notifications
Clear all

A logical Riddle...

25 Posts
20 Users
0 Reactions
421 Views
(@hiro0015)
Posts: 2915
Famed Member
Topic starter
 

You are stuck in a room with two doors. One leads to certain death and the other leads to safety. Each door is guarded by a guard that either tells the truth or always tells a lie, but you don't know which. And they only answer questions with "yes" or "no". You can only ask one question to determine which door leads to safety.

What is the question that you need to ask?

(please note, you cannot maim, disable, kill, or distract the guards in any way)

 
(@mista-bubonic)
Posts: 217
Reputable Member
 

which of these doors lead to safety? *holds 20 dollar bill* neither door?

 
(@ctsucks-007)
Posts: 432
Reputable Member
 

I'd ask them if their dead. o.o
If they say "yes" then their the lying one...
If they say "no" then their the truthfuil one...

...and then I'd ask one of them which one of the doors lead to safety and take the approppriate course of action.

EDIT: DAMN, I forgot I can only ask one question.

 
(@steebay31)
Posts: 2610
Famed Member
 

"Which way to the bathroom?"

 
 Pach
(@pach)
Posts: 2234
Noble Member
 

"Does this door lead to safety and are you alive?"

Truth sayer in front of safe door would say yes.
Truth sayer in front of danger door couldn't respond because it'd be a no/yes conflict.

Liar in front of safety door would say no.
Liar in front of danger door couldn't respond because it'd be a no/yes conflict.

If you ask that question you should escape. Whichever guard says No, use the other guard. Whichever guard says Yes, use him.

CT was a magical inspiration but I decided to combine the two question phrased as one 8O.

 
(@nukeallthewhales_1722027993)
Posts: 1044
Noble Member
 

I would use the power of the internets to find the answer to such a riddle the spoil it for everyone :D

 
(@magenta-darkwolfe)
Posts: 178
Estimable Member
 

Push either guard into the door behind him. Since he cannot be harmed, if it is the safe door, he'll be fine, if it's the danger door, he'll bounce off.

 
(@hiro0015)
Posts: 2915
Famed Member
Topic starter
 

Bub linked the correct answer in chat...

Quote:


Ask either guard, "If I asked the other guy if this door you are guarding is the door to freedom, would he say yes?" If you get a "no" answer, it is safe to use the door. Here's why:

* You might have talked to the LIAR guarding the door to FREEDOM. If so, you would get a "no" answer, since the other guard, the truth-teller, would say yes, so the liar you are talking to would say no.
* If you were talking to the TRUTH-TELLER guarding the door to FREEDOM, you would also get a "no" answer, since the other guard, the liar would say "no" and the guard you were talking to would truthfully report this to you.
* If you were talking to the LIAR guarding the door to DEATH, you would get a "yes" answer.
* If you were talking to the TRUTH-TELLER guarding the door to DEATH, you would also get a "yes" answer.


Pach's answer was "Would you be willing to go through this door and does the other guard always lie?"

I had originally thought to change Pach's to "Would you and would he?" but that yields the exact same answers...

 
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
New Member Guest
 

What if the person who told you only one guard lies was a liar himself?

 
(@crimson-darkwolfe)
Posts: 2232
Noble Member
 

Then you thow HIM through a door.

 
(@spiner-storm)
Posts: 2016
Noble Member
 

I swear I saw that episode of Yu-Gi-Oh.

 
(@gyserhog)
Posts: 1241
Noble Member
 

All I have in my mind is David Bowie and tight pants...

 
(@nuchtos)
Posts: 1134
Noble Member
 

This seems appropriate.

Also that one scene in 10th Kingdom with the frog. I'd link to a video of it but my youtube-fu is weak.

E: lol html

 
(@darkmessiah-forte)
Posts: 131
Estimable Member
 

Knights and Knaves

TV Tropes Wiki has an entry on this sort of thing and more examples.

 
(@hiro0015)
Posts: 2915
Famed Member
Topic starter
 

lol @ Nuch... I might print that up for extra extra credit :D

 
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
New Member Guest
 

I remember something like this on Samurai Jack =D

 
(@samanfur-the-fox)
Posts: 2116
Noble Member
 

It's a coomon riddle - but yes, The 10th Kingdom's spin on it put a fresh twis into a tired formula (although I won't spoil it by saying why...).

 
(@sandygunfox)
Posts: 3468
Famed Member
 

the Samurai Jack one was funnier because both lied. XD

 
(@silver-the-hedgehog)
Posts: 383
Reputable Member
 

Relevant.

 
(@the-cjtails)
Posts: 300
Reputable Member
 

I find it worrying that I read through the answer to this over and over and it just serves to confuse me more and more.

Maybe I am too tired.

Though this does remind me of a question posed to the player at the beginning of Baldurs Gate 2 - though that one had no right answer and was just to see how you would respond.

 
(@darkwinguk)
Posts: 679
Honorable Member
 

Ah, Labyrinth...

Although I think a Pratchett book had the best answer involving something along the lines of "and by the way, whichever door you pick, *you're* going through first!"

Sometimes rephrasing it helps, CJ. *ponders* Actually, it's really difficult to phrase! How about:

Option A) You're asking the liar. The other guy is therefore the guy who tells the truth. You ask the liar which door would the other guy recommend. So the liar would tell you the door, which you wouldn't go through - because he'd lie about what the truthful guy would say.

Option B) You're talking to the truthful guy. If you ask him which door the other dude would recommend, he'll tell you the truth. Since the other guy is a liar, the other guy would recommend the wrong door. So you go through the other one.

Either way, you go through whichever door the guard doesn't recommend.

And Sarah chose the right door - she just chose to continue down when she should have chosen up and hence ended up in an oubliette in the middle of nowhere. Hoggle to the rescue!

DW

PS No, I haven't seen Labyrinth loads of times, why do you ask? ;)

 
(@the-cjtails)
Posts: 300
Reputable Member
 

I THINK I get it a little bit easier now...

I may need a diagram of my own to get it more.

I don't see how I am finding it so hard though x.x

 
(@sonic-whammy)
Posts: 74
Estimable Member
 

Actually, interesting that you ask that question here at the MF. That same situation showed up in Sonic: In Your Face. Sally faced a two-headed dragon with the same dilemma.

And the hedgehog and his princess bring everything full circle... aah...

 
(@ctsucks-007)
Posts: 432
Reputable Member
 

SONIC x AMY forevah!

 
(@the-turtle-guy)
Posts: 3756
Famed Member
 

Sonic doesn't like Amy. o.o Romantically. Rouge either. The 'hog's gay.

 
Share: