Mobius Forum Archive

What is supposed to...
 
Notifications
Clear all

What is supposed to be the difference between Amy's point-of-view on Sonic(GAMES) and Mina's point-of-view on Sonic(COMICS)?

62 Posts
18 Users
0 Reactions
332 Views
(@matthayter700)
Posts: 781
Prominent Member
 

<strong class="quote-title" B Vulpix wrote:


- Madonna!

She makes me think of Bulma...or that Launch character from DragonBall

Ok fair enough, the idea was there... anyway, my point was more so about the "who was there first" reasoning, and how if you apply it consistently, it would point more so to either Sonic being without a girlfriend or with Madonna...

 
(@matthayter700)
Posts: 781
Prominent Member
 

<strong class="quote-title" B Vulpix wrote:


- Madonna!

She makes me think of Bulma...or that Launch character from DragonBall

Ok fair enough, the idea was there... anyway, my point was more so about the "who was there first" reasoning, and how if you apply it consistently, it would point more so to either Sonic being without a girlfriend or with Madonna...

 
(@craig-bayfield)
Posts: 4885
Illustrious Member
 

Matt, you're going across canons on a definitive match with Sonic.

Amy is not a contender for Sonic's affections in the Archie comic. Comparing her with Sally is like trying to work out if the red ranger and the yellow ranger are a true pairing without stating which Power Ranger spin-off you're referring to.

There's no "Who came first" mentality, as neither person is on the same race track. Both are fighting for the affections of a different Sonic The Hedgehog. One the SegaSonic one, and the other the Archie one.

Any further relationship discussion would break Mobius Forum rules.

Suffice to let it rest at Sonic has no girlfriend. This is a fact. Any speculation on who he will end up with is against MoFo discussion rules.

 
(@craig-bayfield)
Posts: 4885
Illustrious Member
 

Matt, you're going across canons on a definitive match with Sonic.

Amy is not a contender for Sonic's affections in the Archie comic. Comparing her with Sally is like trying to work out if the red ranger and the yellow ranger are a true pairing without stating which Power Ranger spin-off you're referring to.

There's no "Who came first" mentality, as neither person is on the same race track. Both are fighting for the affections of a different Sonic The Hedgehog. One the SegaSonic one, and the other the Archie one.

Any further relationship discussion would break Mobius Forum rules.

Suffice to let it rest at Sonic has no girlfriend. This is a fact. Any speculation on who he will end up with is against MoFo discussion rules.

 
(@jinsoku-sonichqcommunity)
Posts: 620
Honorable Member
 

Well, my expert opinion is that this DOES belong in Knothole mainly because it involves Archie comic characters, and story lines, and comparisons between both the game and comic Amy versions.

My other expert opinion is that this wouldn't really constitute as a "relationship" talk as it's not really an, "OMG X should TOTALLY be with X, amirite!?" topic. It's, sadly, a surprisingly well put argument, (though, personally, there's no difference IMO). So, it shouldn't get canned when I move it to Knothole. But that's just me, as Craigipoo has spoken.

For my final expert observation, it's all very stupid anyway.

Also, I'm still moving it.

*MOVED FOR JUSTICE*

 
(@jinsoku-sonichqcommunity)
Posts: 620
Honorable Member
 

Well, my expert opinion is that this DOES belong in Knothole mainly because it involves Archie comic characters, and story lines, and comparisons between both the game and comic Amy versions.

My other expert opinion is that this wouldn't really constitute as a "relationship" talk as it's not really an, "OMG X should TOTALLY be with X, amirite!?" topic. It's, sadly, a surprisingly well put argument, (though, personally, there's no difference IMO). So, it shouldn't get canned when I move it to Knothole. But that's just me, as Craigipoo has spoken.

For my final expert observation, it's all very stupid anyway.

Also, I'm still moving it.

*MOVED FOR JUSTICE*

 
(@ctsucks-666)
Posts: 1982
Noble Member
 

Well, my expert opinion is that this DOES belong in Knothole mainly because it involves Archie comic characters, and story lines, and comparisons between both the game and comic Amy versions.

My other expert opinion is that this wouldn't really constitute as a "relationship" talk as it's not really an, "OMG X should TOTALLY be with X, amirite!?" topic. It's, sadly, a surprisingly well put argument, (though, personally, there's no difference IMO). So, it shouldn't get canned when I move it to Knothole. But that's just me, as Craigipoo has spoken.

For my final expert observation, it's all very stupid anyway.

Also, I'm still moving it.

*MOVED FOR JUSTICE*

I'm not sure how I feel about that.

 
(@ctsucks-666)
Posts: 1982
Noble Member
 

Well, my expert opinion is that this DOES belong in Knothole mainly because it involves Archie comic characters, and story lines, and comparisons between both the game and comic Amy versions.

My other expert opinion is that this wouldn't really constitute as a "relationship" talk as it's not really an, "OMG X should TOTALLY be with X, amirite!?" topic. It's, sadly, a surprisingly well put argument, (though, personally, there's no difference IMO). So, it shouldn't get canned when I move it to Knothole. But that's just me, as Craigipoo has spoken.

For my final expert observation, it's all very stupid anyway.

Also, I'm still moving it.

*MOVED FOR JUSTICE*

I'm not sure how I feel about that.

 
(@matthayter700)
Posts: 781
Prominent Member
 

Matt, you're going across canons on a definitive match with Sonic.

Amy is not a contender for Sonic's affections in the Archie comic. Comparing her with Sally is like trying to work out if the red ranger and the yellow ranger are a true pairing without stating which Power Ranger spin-off you're referring to.

There's no "Who came first" mentality, as neither person is on the same race track. Both are fighting for the affections of a different Sonic The Hedgehog. One the SegaSonic one, and the other the Archie one.

Any further relationship discussion would break Mobius Forum rules.

Suffice to let it rest at Sonic has no girlfriend. This is a fact. Any speculation on who he will end up with is against MoFo discussion rules.

Actually Craig, I didn't even know that Sonic didn't have a girlfriend; as I said earlier I hadn't been following the ArchieSonic story for a while... but yeah since it's been moved to Knothole I guess I'll have to stop now...

 
(@matthayter700)
Posts: 781
Prominent Member
 

Matt, you're going across canons on a definitive match with Sonic.

Amy is not a contender for Sonic's affections in the Archie comic. Comparing her with Sally is like trying to work out if the red ranger and the yellow ranger are a true pairing without stating which Power Ranger spin-off you're referring to.

There's no "Who came first" mentality, as neither person is on the same race track. Both are fighting for the affections of a different Sonic The Hedgehog. One the SegaSonic one, and the other the Archie one.

Any further relationship discussion would break Mobius Forum rules.

Suffice to let it rest at Sonic has no girlfriend. This is a fact. Any speculation on who he will end up with is against MoFo discussion rules.

Actually Craig, I didn't even know that Sonic didn't have a girlfriend; as I said earlier I hadn't been following the ArchieSonic story for a while... but yeah since it's been moved to Knothole I guess I'll have to stop now...

 
(@spiner-storm)
Posts: 2016
Noble Member
 

The opening poster is clearly referring to the points-of-view of the girls BEFORE anything was settled. He's referring to the time when both girls had a particular thing in common. Use some common sense.

Hi, and welcome to the MoFo. We have a lack of common sense around here.

 
(@spiner-storm)
Posts: 2016
Noble Member
 

The opening poster is clearly referring to the points-of-view of the girls BEFORE anything was settled. He's referring to the time when both girls had a particular thing in common. Use some common sense.

Hi, and welcome to the MoFo. We have a lack of common sense around here.

 
Page 2 / 2
Share: