Sonic and Knuckles. Same reason as above.
-
removed sig ~ HSW
Sonic 3. Ice Cap Zone FTW.
S&K was cool becuase it playing as Knuckles in Mushroom Hill for the first time felt completely different from the Sonic formula I was used to from S2. It was cool and difficult and odd and fun and had lock on, which was awesome on many degrees. So Sonic and Knuckles has my vote.
AND DANGIT LSX KILL THAT SIG IT STRETCHES THE TABLES TERRIBLY
I VOTE S&K! I find it about 2 Gum Gums more fun than Sonic 3...
Yeah, that was a One Piece reference...
Man, we went from extremely easy choices to extremely hard ones...
I guess I'll have to go with Sonic and Knuckles. S3 was amazing, but Sonic and Knuckles, of course, kicked the plot into overdrive. The only downfall it had was no save feature.
Sonic and Knuckles, baby.
Sonic 3. The Save choice was AWESOME.
Tho' S&K was very, VERY good. VERY...
...
>_<
I HATE YOU!!
...
I change my vote to S&K. NO! Sonic 3...
<flips a coin>
Sonic 3 gets my vote =P
And I propose that from now on, instead of ending each round with 6 votes, we end them with like, 12 or 10-
Since these are just much, MUCH more important =P
That screwed up sig needs to be edited out and pronto. 
Anyway, S&K wins!
SAFER THAN YO MOMMA GAMES: Sonic 2, S&K
SUPER SAFE GAMES: Chaotix, 3D Blast, SA, SA2, Battle, Rush.
Next round:
Knuckles' Chaotix
Sonic 3D Blast: Flickie's Island (Saturn)
My vote's for 3D Blast. As much as I love Chaotix, 3D has been a game I've played consistently over the years and always enjoyed.
I'm sorry but, CHAOTIX has got my vote. =D
I haven't played Chaotix...
So I'll have to go with 3D Blast.
Even though I haven't played it, I know it features Metal Sonic, Knuckles, and Mighty, that's enough to get my vote. 😛
Sonic 3D Blast definately, sure it's not traditional Sonic, but it does have.
- Superior Music
- More stages
- Awesome Boss Battles
- Great Level Design
- A good sense of Exploration involved!
Wheras after a while, Chaotix started to get very dull, very fast for me, doing the same act 5 times...I found myself giving up exploring and just having to Throw my characters around randomly until I got to the end...
So yeah, I VOTE SONIC 3D BLAST!
what the heck version of Chaotix did you play?
hard choice...ugh.
But Chaotix gets my vote I loved the level select method. the rubber band thing was not hard at all to master, people have a hard time with that thing for some reason...
great special stages, better bosses, and I dare say better graphics at times.
Chaotix
Sonic 3D Blast!
Chaotix got boring fast, I played through it very quickly just to get to the end.
4-3 so far, in 3D's favour.
Sonic 3D Blast. I loved the overall atmosphere of the game, and the music was superb. I just couldn't get into Chaotix's gameplay -- I might've had fun with it if I had a Genesis controller.
I've also enjoyed Sonic 3D blast for many years.
3d was kind of boring so my vote is for chaotix
3d Blast FTW. ^^
3D Blast wins by 2 pts.
Wow, the competitions now sure are coming close o_O
3D wins!
SAFER THAN YO MOMMA GAMES: Sonic 2, S&K, 3D Blast
SUPER SAFE GAMES: SA, SA2, Battle, Rush.
Next, it's the battle of the titans. This round's gonna get messy.
Sonic Adventure
-versus-
Sonic Adventure 2 (Battle)
I'm gonna go with SA. It just feels far more polished than its predecessor.
DING DING DING!
DUN
DUN
DUUUUUUUUN.
And thus begins the Battle between the two Sonic games that will live in infamy.
It's like "Sonic" verses "Sonic 2"
Sonic was classic, but Sonic 2 updated much of the flaws, added a sweet 2 player mode, and looks nicer.
As much as I LUUUV Sonic Adventure (Trust me, it's AMAZING)
The whole feel and addiction and Shadow and Rouge of Sa2, plus the updates and the chao...
It's a pretty simple choice for me, Sonic Adventure 2 gets the win.
SA
Pros-
Playing as Tails WITHOUT A MACHINE <cough cough>
Simple and fun Treasure Hunting Stages
Simple and addictive Shooting Levels (To an extent...)
Story Mode having 6 characters, each with intertwining plots
Flaws-
BIG
FISHING
Annoying animation (Sonich as SHINY teeth :O)
Kinda hard knowing where to go sometimes
Awkward handling (especcially when trying to go fast)
Bad VAs
SA2
Pros-
Playing as Eggman! w00t!
Intro to Shadow, great character and great story.
Improved Light Speed Dash! No more charging!
Improved Chao garden.
Less glitches
REWARD for getting all Emblems
Great replay value (Intro to the A, B, C, and E ranks)
Space Colony Ark levels
2 Player mode
Cons-
Sonic looks...weird...
Tails in a dumb machine.
Bad VAs
Awkward interuptions between conversations (Sonic talking to Shadow on Prison Island- what was up with that?)
Worse Treasure Hunting Levels
I haven't played SA2.. would it be fair if I voted SA then?
Absolutely. You wouldn't be the first person to vote for a game cause they haven't played the alternative (or voted for a game they hadn't actually played.)
Sonic Adventure 1!
By far, the best 3D Sonic title to date. It also introduced Gamma, one of my favourite characters in the series.
I vote for SA, better than SA2 in every way
4-1 for SA.
SONIC ADVENTURE!
I could go into depth to explain why it is the superior game, but I know that everyone here already KNOWS why, so let's not deny the obvious.
Sure, SA2 was good fun, I found no problem with the game, but SA1 was just so much better!
I VOTE SONIC ADVENTURE
Sonic Adventure.
Number 2 has several tedious levels, a dubious plot, and some unpopular characters- and, frankly, felt less like a Sonic game. 1 had the odd spot of fishing.
Sonic Adventure.
Wow, lotsa support for the SA o_O
Y'all forgot about Shadow!
Anyway, SA wins.
wish i could forget about shadow but they keep ramming him down my throat
Matt's been gone for a while..
If he don't come back tomorrow I'm starting the round for him.
<GASPS>
Once Rush and Battle are finished-
We're gonna have 5 games left!
:O How are we gonna divide that?
lolz, last minute vote. nN
Sonic Adventure 1.
SA wins!
SAFER THAN YO MOMMA GAMES: Sonic 2, S&K, 3D Blast, SA
SUPER SAFE GAMES: Battle, Rush.
Next games:
Sonic Battle
Sonic Rush
Go, Battle!
I'm torn. oo
I love Battle.
I love Rush.
...Battle gets it. I'm sorry Rush! I've betrayed you!!!
lolz. Battle FTW.
Rush failed me due to lack of DS. n_N
Battle!
I vote for battle, it was an arguably a good game. (SEGA faints)
Quote:<hr
:"> O How are we gonna divide that?
We're most likely to do a free for all. That or one of the games go automatically though.
Sonic Rush.
Battle has a great story, and I love the artwork, but as a fighting game it's pretty weak when compared to Super Smash Bros., Power Stone, and even Sonic The Fighters, plus the fighting can be irritating and frustrating and the music may as well be turned off. Rush, however, is the best Sonic game since SA1, and is a lot of fun, and the soundtrack is by Hideki Naganuma! ^.^
Rush.
5-2, Battle.
battle was neat and all but it could use a sequal or two to iron out the rough spotts. Rush was a return to fun, insipred, well made Sonic games for a change.
RUSH
Battle was great. Fun gameplay with an awesome story. Though I have to say it got old, fighting the same people so often.
Rush was awesome. A little light on story, but the gameplay is a blast. Plus, I'm a platform-gamer through and through.
Go Rush.
AAHHHH
Sonic Battle was awesome in almost every way and is one of my favorite Sonic games ever.
I've never played Sonic Rush but I've heard it's wonderful.
MMMRRRR
I'll go Battle because it's all I'm familiar with.
Battle wins by 2 pts! O_O <omfg>
I didn't even get to vote -_-
Oh well, I haven't played either of them.
So now we're in the Semi-Finals, eh?
Whoa, I almost missed this one...
even though Battle has one, I would have still votet for it!
Battle wins!
SAFER THAN YO MOMMA GAMES: Sonic 2, S&K, 3D Blast, SA, Battle
Now, before we can get to the semi-finals, one of these games needs to be eliminated. So here's how it will work:
To get a fair cross-section of games, the first, middle, and last game will go up against each other. When you vote, vote for two games. The first two games to reach six votes will make it through and the game that doesn't will be eliminated.
In this round:
Sonic the Hedgehog 2 (Genesis/Mega Drive)
Sonic 3D Blast: Flickie's Island (Saturn)
Sonic Battle
My votes are for Sonic 2 and 3D Blast.
Ooh, nice idea.
I'll go with Sonic 2 and 3D blast as well my man!
same here
2 and 3D
Sonic 2 and Sonic Battle.
But I see where you're going with this. Eventually it will coem down to SA1 and S&K. nN
Battle and Sonic 2.
