This is where the whole Sonic community slaps their foreheads in disgruntledness....."D'OH!"
Still, very good round, Bomb and Heavy have no love, I never really considered them as true characters, but at the end of the day, they're not enemies, and you can control them...
Can't believe it was right. 😛
I pass my turn for I am lazy to make clues.
Ooh, okay, I got it.
1). Strawberries
2). Not light of foot
3). Created for a purpose
Uh...From Clue 2, I'm gonna reckon it's a heavy char, and we just had Bomb, so why not....BIG THE CAT!?
I'm guessing Amy Rose
1) Strawberries -> pink fur/spines
2) Not light of foot -> she carries a hammer
3) Created for a purpose -> created to be the damsel in distress.
Nope to both =D
Lols. It's Cream.
1) Strawberries. And Cream!
2) Not light of foot. But light as a feather, as Cream can use her ears to flap and fly.
3) Created for a purpose. Be an extra character in the Sonic Advance series, because Shadow and Rouge weren't cool enough =O
Yup, that it's. Although:
2 - was a reference to Johnny Lightfoot, rabbit of the Fleetway comics
3 - Cream was created to be a flight character in Heroes
Ha ha, I thought it might have been a Johnny Lightfoot reference!
=P Man, I was just kidding around with it, too. I wasn't expecting (but secretly hoping) to be right.
But, anyway, I reluctantly give up my position to whoever wants it, because to be quite honest, I'm just downright sucky at making these. =P
I'll go again!
1). Similar to another character
2). Abrupt appearance
3). Abrupt disappearance
Gamma!
1. -> similar to Omega
2. -> he just appeared out of nowhere
3. -> he blew himself up.
Nope.
Blaze cuz shes similar to big (purple cat) and she popped into our diminsion and then out again
No.
I'm gonna guess Heavy, just in case someone's trying to pull a fast one. 
Nope. =p
Nack?
My reasons
1. he came out of nowhere
2. he totally disapeared from the games
3 and is similar to rouge in that they are both treasure hunters.
Omega, I think.
He is a lot like Gamma, and he really did enter abruptly =P
No to both!
Man, that's 5 people who haven't gotten it yet.
Lemme try again...
Tails Doll? (I wanna see him again!!!)
Shadow?
1. some say he looks like Sonic
2. and 3. This could be reffering to the fact that he can appear and disappear with Chaos Control.
No to both again!
4. First appeared post-SA
Tikal? Similar to Knuckles, ect.
Black Doom?
1). Similar to another character
Similar to Shadow
2). Abrupt appearance
Poof! Out of nowhere in the start of the game.
3). Abrupt disappearance
I think so.
4). First appeared post-SA
Self-explanatory.
Nope!
Gerald Robotnik? o.o
I'm guessing Void
1). Similar to another character
NiGHTS
4). First appeared post-SA
Self explanatory.
If Void's wrong, I'll guess Lumina for the same reasons, but we'll see...
Nope!
Jeebus. This is really crazy...
Possibly...Cream's Mom? I didn't play the game but I heard that she's just...there...and then she just...goes away or soemthing o_O
Nup.
OMOCHAO!
1) Similar to another character - That being the Chao.
2) Abrupt appearance - He'd appear every now and then in levels in SA2.
3) Abrupt disappearance - Haven't really seen him since SA2, but we know he still exists because that's meant to be his voice in Sonic Riders.
4) First appeared post-SA - First appeared in Sonic Adventure 2.
Nup.
5). Similar to a previous guess.
Ok...what were the guesses that fit the criteria:
Blaze
Omega
Shadow
Black Doom
Gerald Robotnik
Void
Cream's Mom
Omochao
And it's similar to any of those?
Alright...we got a cat, a robot, a human, a creation, an alien, a dream, and a bunny.
The games that came out after Sonic Adventure were:
Sonic Shuffle
Sonic Adventure 2
Sonic Advance Series
Sonic Battle
Sonic Heroes
Sonic Rush
Well, I'm gonna have to go with Lumina or Emerl.
...
Gemerl. Or however you want to spell it.
1) Similar to another character - Similar to Emerl, from Sonic Battle.
2) Abrupt appearance - Suddenly appeared in Sonic Advance 3, after Emerl's demise in Sonic Battle
3) Abrupt disappearance - Haven't really seen him since Sonic Advance 3, since that supposedly takes place towards the end of the game series.
4) First appeared post-SA - First appeared in Sonic Advance 3. I could clarify that as being post-SA.
5) Similar to a previous guess. - He's a robot. Duh.
Nup!
O_O ...(getting old...)
Alright...Silver?
I'd throw in the reasons but they might be spoilers.
Did anyone say Eggman Nega...?
No and no!
The genie (Babylon Guardian) from Sonic Riders?
Similar to Jet in looks, abruptly appears and disappears, first appeared post SA. Don't know how it's similar to a previous guess though.
Incorrect
Well, i did guess Void or Lumina earlier...hmmm..
Illumina!?
Nup!
7). It's not a Shuffle or Riders character
Guesses made:
the genie (Babylon Guardian) from Sonic Riders
Lumina
Void
Illumina
Blaze
Omega
Shadow
Black Doom
Gerald Robotnik
Cream's Mom
Omochao
Gemerl
Silver
Eggman Nega
Emerl
1). Similar to another character
2). Abrupt appearance
3). Abrupt disappearance
4). First appeared post-SA
5). Similar to a previous guess.
6). It's not a Shuffle or Riders character
Hmmm...
Metal Overlord?
Nope!
Silver/Mecha Knuckles (Sonic Advance)?
Matt, that was a great idea to tell us it's the character's not from Sonic Shuffle after we went through each character in it =P
Ok ok ok...
I'm gonna guess 3 since I just wanna get one RIGHT!
Charmy
Espio
Vector
ANY of those??
The Biolizard?
Gerald Robotnik?
1). Similar to another character - Eggman
2). Abrupt appearance - Suddenly appears in SA2's final chapter and Eggman's just like "It's my Grandfather...wtf?"
3). Abrupt disappearance - Well he got shot, that was pretty abrupt.
4). First appeared post-SA - SA2
5). Similar to a previous guess. - Did anyone guess Eggman?
6). It's not a Shuffle or Riders character - Mua ha ha
No, no, no, no, no, no.
7). The characters referred to in #1 and #7 are different.
