Mobius Forum Archive

Who do you think is...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Who do you think is the worst Sonic character?

167 Posts
36 Users
0 Reactions
124 Views
(@john-taylor_1722027898)
Posts: 1827
Noble Member
 

Didn't Cream hop in Sonic Battle?

I do agree that there is something to hate in all Sonic characters but you will always end up liking some characters for wierd reasons and you always end up hating others.

 
(@hyper-sonic-warrior)
Posts: 1355
Noble Member
 

Her dash is a hop, yes

 
(@harley-quinn-hyenaholic)
Posts: 1269
Noble Member
 

Cream is WEAK. Without Cheese she wouldn't be able to do Jack.

Although it begs the question, if she's weak, why is Sonic Advance 2 a walkthrough when you play as her?

 
(@rico-underwood)
Posts: 2928
Famed Member
 

I can't argue when there are no real reasons given to argue against.

BTW. New haircut, Harley?

 
(@super-rayzor_1722027929)
Posts: 1381
Noble Member
 

Quote:


Cream is WEAK. Without Cheese she wouldn't be able to do Jack.


I don't know why people say Cream would be weak without Cheese, I mean Cream can do everything that Sonic can do. She can spin dash, she has super speed, and her spin jump can destroy robots just like Sonic's does and then in addition to all those things, she has her flight. So, with or without Cheese, Cream is far from weak unless you want to say Sonic is weak without a kamikaze chao.

 
(@beardie99)
Posts: 68
Trusted Member
 

Tails Doll! Tails Doll would've been a good character if Sega/Sonic Team/Travelers Tales would've been a good character if they put some thought in his character.

 
(@john-taylor_1722027898)
Posts: 1827
Noble Member
 

Sush! you'll wake...it. >_>

<_<
Tails Doll is just that. A Doll. A Doll with no soul. I might have said too much.

*flees*

 
(@jet-k)
Posts: 407
Reputable Member
 

I don't really know if there IS a worst character. I guess it depends on what you like in the games. I personally don't HATE Cream. I just don't entirely see her as neccessary. The same could probably be said about all the characters to some degree. I'm not saying that any are 100% unneccessary though.

 
(@harley-quinn-hyenaholic)
Posts: 1269
Noble Member
 

Damn right, Rico.

Do you know how RUDE it is to suggest that I might take offence at a suggestion so accurate?

I HATE YOU!!!

SO SHUT UP!!!

Cream is probably the least interesting character ever. She doesn't get much attention from the comics, even.

I HATE EVERYTHING!

So stop complaining.

 
(@jet-k)
Posts: 407
Reputable Member
 

I've actually been wondering if Cream will EVER be in the comic? O.O I don't know just wondering I guess.

 
(@rico-underwood)
Posts: 2928
Famed Member
 

She's so cute when she's exploding in fits of delusional rage.

 
(@harley-quinn-hyenaholic)
Posts: 1269
Noble Member
 

I quite like Big, in case anybody's wondering. He's more interesting than Cream. Cream's too young. And if you know what I'm talking about, then shame on you too.

*b****slaps Rico*

That's for saying my rage is delusional!

 
(@rico-underwood)
Posts: 2928
Famed Member
 

Yes harley's only interesting in character old enough for her sordid affairs. Watch out Cream, as soon as you hit Tails' age.

 
 Kaze
(@kaze)
Posts: 2723
Famed Member
 

@ Jet K: Probably never. The only comic she actually is in is Archie's Sonic X comic.

Though I think your question should really be in the Knothole forum, just to be safe.

While still on the subject of Cream (again), Sega/Sonic Team should at least have developed her character more in a few ways. With the exception of Sonic Battle and episode 46 of Sonic X, she really doesn't do anything. And I consider that a bad thing.

She's a good character. One of my favorites as I've said before. She and Cheese just sit there and gather dust as time goes on...

 
(@harley-quinn-hyenaholic)
Posts: 1269
Noble Member
 

You're so cruel, Rico. One day I'll be fantastically famous and...

(delusional fantasies ahoy!)

*twenty minutes later*

...and that was the reason I sold my soul to Satan for the first time.

 
(@baby-amy)
Posts: 16
Active Member
 

"Shadow and Cream are marketable, but I don't think that justifies the fact that they're poor characters, cheap imitations of the first two heroes and don't fit in with the image the series had. They're both redundant characters, shoe-horned into the series."

*Reads Cream rants* I agree with CVP. Just because Cream is marketable doesn't mean she isn't a poor character. I don't hate Cream I just dislike her. Nothing about her appeals to me. She's suppose to represent innocents huh? But wasn't Tails representing innocents in the first place. Tails is still innocent, nowhere in his character represents him as an action packed character. He is quiet, shy and is the type of character who would rather find a non-violent resolution. Given that Eggman is headstrong about his goal thats not really an option for Tails now is it? Cream and Tails both have innocents. They are even around the same age as each other (6 and 8 not too far apart). So why I dislike Cream and not Tails? She sticks out like a sore thumb to the point where it's almost obvious she does not fit into the Sonic series. Her purpose almost feels forced just for marketing purposes. She doesn't care to fight and even refuses to fight in Sonic Battle while Emerl is getting his butt kicked (if I remember correctly) other then marking purposes she's poor character IMO. They already have innocents in the game why do they have to have babyish kind of innocents in an Action/Adventure game. It just doesn't fit. Cream's type of innocents is better off in a Whiney the Pooh adventure game rather then a Sonic game. And speaking as a girl (when I was a little girl before) I probably wouldn't care for Cream back then either because I looked up to older girls or boy characters in a game because I wanted to be like them. From the numerous little kids around 6 that come to my house (I have a huge family with little kids okay) and play my Sonic games, I have yet to see one of them pick Cream first to play with because she appealed to them. So if Cream really is suppose to be marketed for Little kids then Sonic Team needs to rethink on what they are doing.

As for Cream in Sonic X, yes she did fight. ONLY twice out of the 78 episodes where they could have used her help at times in other eps. She did more nothing and crying then she did help. Point is I don't like Cream. If anyone disagrees with me (or hates me for it) or not, It doesn't matter I still don't like her thats just my opinion of her.

(BTW, I use to like Cream a lot just because she was cute, but cuteness doesn't substitute for Character depth.)

 
(@hypersonic2003)
Posts: 5035
Illustrious Member
 

From what I hear Heavy and Bomb, tanked. *shot* Other than them, i'm not a huge Big fan and I think these new Babylons as cool as they are might be a bit much. Not Blaze no way, she's hip and cool. =)

 
(@spiner-storm)
Posts: 2016
Noble Member
 

Shadow.

BLACK! RED! GUNS! ANGST! CONFUSING PLOT ELEMENTS! EXPLOSIONS! MARIA! CHAOS CONTROL! FIND THE COMPUTER ROOM! BLACK DOOM! SONIC! SHADOW!

Ahem.

No, not really.

...

GUN COMMANDER.
Oh, we all don't like him. I know it. I can smell it. Could have been so much more of a better and interesting character than what he was made out to be.

Poor bastard. *Salute*

...

BLACK DOOM.
Black Doom, despite his appearance in Shadow the Hedgehog, just wasn't as menacing as I had initially anticipated. He's the leader of some sort of diabolical alien race hoping to enslave the Earth, yet he makes for a very weak boss fight, and character over all. He could've been much more evil, and had more sinister plots and ideas, like forcing GUN and the Eggman Empire into battle with each other to decimate the forces, while he swept in after the battle and eliminated the rest with the Black Arms.

But, no.

In the end, he was kind of soft, even after transforming into Devil Doom. The final boss battle was the good thing about him, but it wasn't enough to redeem him.

...

ROUGE THE BAT.
Sexy seductress my arse. She didn't need to be introduced to the franchise in the first place when they had a very good character sitting in the back collecting dust, Nack the Weasel, otherwise known as Fang the Sniper. Just a pity that they couldn't use him, 'coz they needed to fill up the gaps for more female characters.

I wasn't particularly fond of her character from the beginning, nor I still am today.

SHADOW X AMY! =D

...

Sorry 'bout that.

There may be some more, but I don't want to think of them right now.

 
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
New Member Guest
 

I think all characters in Shadow the Hedgehog should be henceforth excluded from this topic as they're nothing but 2-dimensional caricatures with insipid names. I mean, 'Black Doom'? Really, SEGA?

 
(@kamirinegoddess)
Posts: 21
Eminent Member
 

I haven't laughed so hard in a while. This thread is a hoot!

Let's see, who can I pick on...

Big the Cat:
The only thing I like about Big was that in Sonic Heroes, his voice made me laugh. Cringe. But laugh. Everytime I heard it. Otherwise, a 20 year old cat hanging out with girls under the age of 13 is just NOT cool...

Sonic
I don't hate him, I just think he needs more depth to him. Other than "I save the day for no reason other than it's fun. Oh...and it might be the right thing to do."

Cream
To add to this little debate: I don't hate Cream, but I do find that she can be *useless* in my opinion too. Other than plot most of the time, she really is.
And I do admit: I hate that fact that she can fly. I mean Tails can fly for a limited time. Knuckles can at leasts glide. Rouge can fly. Super Sonic/Shadow can fly. Heck, even Eggman flies in his Egg Carrier of doom. Did we NEED another character that takes to the air? Seriously?
Other than that, I find that she's a *bit* of a Mary Sue, but the fact that she's only six makes me feel better about it, because I usually completely hate those type of characters.

Shadow
Okay, I don't hate him either. Actually, I rather like him. But I swear beyond all reasons it nearly killed me to play his game. To this day, I want to smack Sega Team over the head for giving him guns. GUNS!! And what in the HELL did he need cars/jeeps--whatever for! I'm surprised they didn't have an unlockable "Pimp My Ride" after you beat the game...
But I'll say one thing: my friends and I had jokes. For weeks. About this game. ::cough::BlingBling::hack::

Comic Wise, I despise Sally. I've never liked her and I probably never will.

And I know this is a silly question but: what game is the Tail's doll in?

 
(@super-rayzor_1722027929)
Posts: 1381
Noble Member
 

Quote:


And I know this is a silly question but: what game is the Tail's doll in?


That, my dear, is a game entitled simply as Sonic R.

 
(@trueblue2005)
Posts: 56
Trusted Member
Topic starter
 

I also agree that Cream is an ok character. I feel that she is just useless at times and has no point, but she is a good addition. I think she should jump instead of going into ball mode though.

Isn't Shadow dead to this day? Isn't he a robot in Sonic Heroes and Shadow the Hedgehog? If he is, they should have just kept him dead, because playing through the game as a robot searching for his past because he thinks he's real is kind of cheesy. Shadow is my favorite character, but if he's just a robot now, what's the point of him? Sega should have just kept him dead, not bring him back as a pointless robot.

 
(@john-taylor_1722027898)
Posts: 1827
Noble Member
 

Spoilers (Select To Read): No the Shadow you play as in Sonic Heroes and Shadow the Hedgehog is the original Shadow from Sonic Adventure 2. Apparently after about 7 minutes on the Devil Doom. Eggman confirms this that he was lying about Shadow being an android and that his robots saved Shadow from the great drop.

And now you know.

 
(@trueblue2005)
Posts: 56
Trusted Member
Topic starter
 

I just read that the real Shadow is in Shadow the Hedgehog, so I have no problem with Shadow returning to Sonic games. I also remember Omega saying that Shadow wasn't dead in Sonic Heroes.

 
(@very-crazy-penguin_1722585704)
Posts: 456
Reputable Member
 

You prefer that they've ruined SA2's ending?

 
(@hypersonic2003)
Posts: 5035
Illustrious Member
 

XD! Only us die-hard Shadow fans could prefer that. *stabbed*

 
(@kamirinegoddess)
Posts: 21
Eminent Member
 

Thanks! For some reason, I thought it was Sonic CD.

 
(@super-rayzor_1722027929)
Posts: 1381
Noble Member
 

Quote:


Thanks! For some reason, I thought it was Sonic CD.


No problemo!:thumbsup

 
(@craig-bayfield)
Posts: 4885
Illustrious Member
 

You prefer that they've ruined SA2's ending?

You speak as if it wasn't ruined in the first place?

 
(@shadowaldrius)
Posts: 222
Estimable Member
 

Well, if he was a robot then atleast his sacrifice would have meant something a bit more substantial.

 
(@evil-lamont-raccoon)
Posts: 2
New Member
 

NACK! The Tails doll, hmmm who else, Metal sonic! Why you ask? Simple. Nack for the sole reason as he cannot fight. He'll get owned by ANY sonic character in 2 seconds... he brings NOTHING new to the table. Metal sonic is NOTHING but a clone of sonic... he has no soul, and I'm sorry, but shadow can kick his "blank" from here to next sunday. He also brings nothing to the table. IMHO And the tails doll was a dull idea. IMHO

Its all most sad that sega gives us something NEW to the series and all you fans ( those who do anyway) do is complain. " I hate shadow.. he's nothing but a recolor..." But isn't mighty and OMG metal sonic is MEANT to be a copy of sonic... wow. But thats my rant. Nothing personal... but it does GET OLD!

 
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
New Member Guest
 

Otherwise, a 20 year old cat hanging out with girls under the age of 13 is just NOT cool...

It's general, although not canon, opinion that Big is 17 and Amy is either 15 or 16. Cream, I don't know, but it's moot.

 
(@sonicknight)
Posts: 139
Estimable Member
 

Quote:


Otherwise, a 20 year old cat hanging out with girls under the age of 13 is just NOT cool...


:( my heart really hurts when i read stuff like this, and I just prayed and all.
does it always has to mean something mega wrong?

look i know it's not right for girls to be with stranger guys without their father or brother with them no matter what age they are, but it's okay if he's mentally undeveloped like Big. also this is a cartoon it really doesn't mean anything bad.

anyway i don't like big, i feel like he's ganna eat cream one day :nn; really, they should have made him loveable like all the cat characters.

i like chubby people their cute and hug like teddy bears (like my friend) they didn't know how to give big that kinda image they put him in the girl's team to make him sweet looking, but ..i don't know, his whole design is wrong. voice, image and story.

 
(@craig-bayfield)
Posts: 4885
Illustrious Member
 

look i know it's not right for girls to be with stranger guys without their father or brother with them no matter what age they are, but it's okay if he's mentally undeveloped like Big. also this is a cartoon it really doesn't mean anything bad.

There is so much wrong with that paragraph I have no idea where to start...

 
(@hypersonic2003)
Posts: 5035
Illustrious Member
 

XD

 
(@very-crazy-penguin_1722585704)
Posts: 456
Reputable Member
 

Big is 18, Amy is 12, Cream is 6.

 
(@sonicknight)
Posts: 139
Estimable Member
 

which part? your older than me, your age my cousin had his second kid dont tell me you dont understand?
If you had a daughter would you let her go with a man unsupervised?
or lets say your wife? Shes older but is it okay to go to a mans apartment?
NO! good girls dont go alone, and good men wouldnt allow girls to go to their homes its inappropriate. Spreads rumors, ruin families, hurt honors or even worse.
and why do you always talk to me when it's these kinda stuff?!!

 
(@craig-bayfield)
Posts: 4885
Illustrious Member
 

Your morality intrigues me, that's all. I'm not picking on you, I just... do you seriously think that all women need an escort? Do you know how overwhelmingly sexist that is? No, I don't think any girl over the age of 14 NEEDS to be accompanied, smoothering like that is just going to cause damage to the poor kid and alienate them from society.

As for the whole justification on Big being dimwitted, are you honestly implying that it would be ok for girls (of any age) to fraternise with mentally disabled people, but not normal men?

It seriously sounds like you're implying that all men are potential sexual predators out to get any unsuspecting and unescorted female, and if that IS your world view. It terrifies me.

 
(@erika-the-ocelot)
Posts: 1037
Noble Member
 

You mean girls can't hang out with male friends?
By your logic I wouldn't be able to go to my afternoon japanese lessons (out of 7 people 5 are male and adults) and I couldn't stay with my two best friends at school.
Sure, this doesn't mean a girl can hang out with anyone she meets, but if you're careful and don't expose yourself to great risks (i.e. going out very late) it's ok. And if some idiot goes too far and stretches his hand where he shouldn't a punch in the face settles everything. =P

 
(@rico-underwood)
Posts: 2928
Famed Member
 

Craigy, I think in is own little way SK is saying that adolescent girls shouldn't go home with pachu- er, I mean strange adult males.

Quote:


You mean girls can't hang out with male friends?


I never saw anyone say that. Who are you talking to?

 
(@sonicknight)
Posts: 139
Estimable Member
 

Quote:


Your morality intrigues me, that's all. I'm not picking on you, I just...


not that, i meant the topics are always embarrassing. cant we argue about the weather or something.

the escort thing is only necessary when theyre alone, in none public areas like his house or hers without the presence of a family member. Thats when its dangerous, even if its a trustful friend, and nothing happens rumors cut deep. And will effect future marriage (their spouse wont trust her/him).

most men are good but the ones that show interest in a girl and invite her to a suspicious place are either with bad intention or careless in which cause unnecessary rumors that will harm both their reputations. Thats why a girl and a guy cant be alone without someone else there. This not only behaves the self, it also teaches respect to opposite genders and honoring your future spouse.

No, not all mentally disabled people are safe to be with, but some are harmless and safe. Big is like that, although Im not too sure thats why I said he might eat cream. (but lets say he is so everyone can enjoy the game:thumbsup okay?)

about the alienating thing: I agree with you, its not healthy and the thought of youths think badly of each other, deeply hurts me. But a simple precaution is needed, go everywhere in the open and with a clear intention. so you wont hurt your friend or yourself:)

 
(@very-crazy-penguin_1722585704)
Posts: 456
Reputable Member
 

It's Sonic the Hedgehog.

 
(@john-taylor_1722027898)
Posts: 1827
Noble Member
 

Firstly LOL @ Rico. You went there... *nods*

Secondly people are looking way too deeply in the whole Big around Cream and Amy. It was only one game he actually had an affiliation with Amy and Cream AKA Team Jubilee. Now he has disappeared into the background. He along with Metal Sonic didn't even appear in Shadow. Which in a way was dissapointing.

He just walks through the chaos saying: The Horror...The Horror.

 
 Kaze
(@kaze)
Posts: 2723
Famed Member
 

Either that or he's looking for Froggy again. :p

 
(@mimiichimu)
Posts: 194
Estimable Member
 

Although I did think it was odd for Big to be with Cream and Amy, as VCP said before, it's Sonic the Hedgehog. No one is implying anything wrong.

What about the other main femmie, Rouge? Sure, she could probably take care of herself, but she hangs around people as skilled as she is (if not more), practically all of them male. Add acting and dressing like she does, being the little seductress. She's only 17. See, I'm thinking too much. I'm surprised no one's mentioned those facts about her in this thread.

 
(@spite_1722585799)
Posts: 439
Reputable Member
 

Quote:


Either that or he's looking for Froggy again.


I like to think he was looking for Forggy during Sonic Adventure 2, that's why he had those cameos he was on his own little adventure - behind the scenes, like an Untold Tale of Spider-man.

 
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
New Member Guest
 

I really don't like how people think Big is retarded or something. I mean, sure. I'll admit, he doesn't know much about anything at all, but that's because for his entire life until the beginning of Sonic Adventure he's been living in the jungle, in his own little world. As far as Big was concerned, up until that point, there was no world outside that little corner of the jungle that he occupied. Aside from all that, he taught himself how to fish for his own food, make his own furniture, and talk. His only friend for his entire life has been a normal, average, everyday frog, who probably doesn't understand a word Big says.
Then, all of a sudden, that's taken away from him, and his only recourse of action is to try and rescue his friend, when he gets tossed into a world of things he's never seen before. This would seem like far too much to handle for anybody one would consider a halfwit, but Big takes it all in stride.
He also demonstrates himself to be an incredibly quick learner by flying Tails' broken plane from the deck of the Egg Carrier to the area directly in front of his house. Considering that the Egg Carrier, directly after this, landed in the ocean on the opposite end of Mystic Ruins from Big's house, one would assume this would take a fair amount of skill to fly a non-functioning plane all the way across the Mystic Ruins and land both without causing a fatal accident (The plane had no landing gear and he was attempting to land in a treed area) and with such a remarkable degree of accuracy.
Thus, Big isn't stupid by any degree; He certainly has no mental deficiencies. For an 18-year-old cat who had never seen the outside world until Sonic Adventure, I think he's done remarkably well for himself.
As for the whole thing about being around Amy and Cream? Big met Amy during Sonic Adventure and as such most likely feels a familiarity towards her, and his childlike innocence causes him to be naturally friendly to people like Cream. Besides, two of the three members of Team Rose share a similar objective, so why wouldn't it make sense for Cream and Big to seek the help of Amy, who had been on more than her share of adventures prior to Heroes?
So stop making fun of the Big guy, people. He really doesn't deserve it.

--Wonderbat--

 
(@cyberknux_1722585730)
Posts: 286
Reputable Member
 

"She's only 17."

Finally an opening to talk about this. I reckon they took her down a year for the Sonic Heroes instruction manual so that the more.. 'worrysome' (ahem) people didn't complain about OMG Knuckles=16 + Rouge=18 = illegal! (despite the fact that's not where your head's supposed to go anyway as this is essentially a kid's series). Only a year's difference from 16-/-18, but I'm sure it'd be enough to get someone fired up :rolleyes

Sonic X's profile card (which aint 100% reliable, I know) lists her as 18, not 17. And now, so does her bio on Sonic Channel. I'd be interested to see the japanese version of the Heroes instruction manual and see which age she is there.

 
(@maverick-sh)
Posts: 270
Reputable Member
 

Besides, he was voiced by Duke freakin' Nukem before the 4Kids takeover, so badmouthing him is just ASKING for the Duke to come to your house to kick your ass and chew your bubblegum, and right when you ran outta gum.

 
(@craig-bayfield)
Posts: 4885
Illustrious Member
 

I like to think he was looking for Forggy during Sonic Adventure 2, that's why he had those cameos he was on his own little adventure - behind the scenes, like an Untold Tale of Spider-man.

Shhh, he's a GUN spy!

and Maria is the President's Secertary. They're not telling you the whole truth!

 
Page 2 / 4
Share: